Ten years ago this week NCE’s cover summed up the destruction of New York’s Twin Towers with a single word: “Unthinkable”.
- Click here to view NCE’s full special report on the World Trade Center collapses and reconstruction, | featuring expert opinions, archive articles, NCE analysis, image galleries, videos and webcams. The entire special report is free to access.
Changing the course of history
Looking back, it remains true. The 11 September terrorist attack was an unimaginable event that changed the course of history, prompting conflict in Iraq and Afghanistan and spawning a new breed of terror attack in London and worldwide.
The realisation that two 417m tall buildings could be felled in less than 90 minutes did also prompt questions about engineers’ role in protecting society from this new threat.
“Certainly the dynamics of what happened are clear to see but could structural engineers have done anything about it?” I asked back then. “As an industry we must learn from what has happened and make whatever adjustments are necessary to design codes − if any turn out to be necessary.”
Ten years on it is clear that engineers have learnt some of the lessons, although some have still to be embraced. It is also clear that, while no-one can rule out attack by aircraft, the skyscraper is here to stay.
Cities across the world continue to develop landmark tall buildings such as Shanghai’s 492m World Financial Center, Hong Kong’s 484m International Finance Centre and the mammoth 828m Burj Kalifa in Dubai. London’s 310m Shard is now under construction, as is the 541m One World Trade Center growing from Ground Zero.
Yet this desire to build ever taller underlines a second, perhaps more important challenge we also highlighted 10 years ago.
“We now better appreciate design for structural resilience and modelling fire impact. Design codes have also been revised. And we have seen very important work done on evacuation strategies”
“We must think about the human side to this tragedy and the work to restore public faith in the infrastructure icons that we help to create,” I wrote. “Having seen the pictures from New York, you could understand if many people thought long and hard about going back to work in the world’s megatowers.”
Perhaps the resilience of human nature has helped to banish any such fears. But I’d argue that it is more likely down to the efforts of the engineering professionals who have demonstrated that high rise structures are still safe.
We now better appreciate design for structural resilience and modelling fire impact. Design codes have also been revised. And we have seen very important work done on evacuation strategies.
As current Standing Committee on Structural Safety chairman Gordon Masterton put it 10 years ago, “living in cities with buildings that we admire and enjoy […] is one of our basic freedoms. We cannot react to the events in New York by cowering away in darkened bunkers. That […] would be a victory for terror.”
We have not and the evidence that the war on terror is being won is evident in the staggering infrastructure that continues to be designed and constructed around us. Long may it continue.
Antony Oliver is NCE’s Editor
Engineers have kept the faith in tall buildings despite 9/11