Your browser is no longer supported

For the best possible experience using our website we recommend you upgrade to a newer version or another browser.

Your browser appears to have cookies disabled. For the best experience of this website, please enable cookies in your browser

We'll assume we have your consent to use cookies, for example so you won't need to log in each time you visit our site.
Learn more

Lack of fire stops blamed for speed of Madrid tower inferno

News

AN ABSENCE of fi re stops between the curtain wall façade and concrete floor slabs has emerged as a critical factor in the rapid spread of fi re that devastated Madrid's Torre Windsor tower block last weekend.

The 32 storey concrete tower in the Spanish capital's central business district remained in danger of collapse as NCE went to press, following the blaze that took 19 hours to extinguish. City offi cials have confi rmed that the building is beyond repair and will have to be pulled down.

The re broke out late on Saturday night on the 21st floor, but within two hours had spread to all fl oors above floor 17, where a massive concrete fl oor slab is designed to isolate fires.

At 1.15am on Sunday morning the north facade fell off down to fl oor 17, with the east, west and part of the south facades following by 5pm. It is believed the isolation slab prevented a progressive collapse.

Arup Fire Madrid director George Faller witnessed the blaze: 'I was driving home from the theatre at about 1am when I saw a big fi eball in the sky. Debris was fl ying off the building.

'The rst part to collapse was the north facade. Steel columns supporting the wall would have expanded and buckled under the heat. Huge fl ames engulfed it all, ' he said.

Farrer believes that this rapid spread of fi e was almost certainly caused by the absence of fire stops.

'The question is how did it spread, and this edge detail needs careful consideration, ' he said.

'It is typical that the fl oor slab does not touch the curtain wall.

So as the curtain wall gets hot it bulges out, increasing the size of the gap and allowing the fire to spread between floors, ' he said.

Faller added that there should be a connection between the fl oor slab and the facade, and an incombustible fi e stop material used to plug the gap.

(continued p6) 'In Madrid the architect is responsible for the fire engineering and I have yet to come across an architect who has been aware of how vital this connection is in terms of fire protection, ' he added.

Other local engineers said that the lack of fi e walls between the central concrete core of the building and the floors contributed to the spread of the blaze.

The building, designed in the 1970s, is not believed to have a sprinkler system (see box).

Instead it was fi tted with smoke and heat detectors and was built with two 'isolating floors' made of thicker concrete to contain fires. The fi st lies between the 2nd and 3rd fl oor, the second between the 16th and 17th.

The upper isolating floor contained the fi re until 5.30am when several outer concrete columns and a section of fl oor slab collapsed. It is believed that this collapse encouraged the fire to spread below floor 17.

The fi e eventually spread to all fl oors above the lower isolating fl oor and was not fully extinguished until 5pm on Saturday evening, 17 hours after the blaze began.

Because of the danger of collapse, engineers have not yet been allowed access to the building. A team from the city authorities was expected to make an inspection on Wednesday.

The cause of the fi re has yet to be determined, although investigators will focus on three possibilities, the Madrid emergency response team Portavoz Emergencia Madrid said this week.

The building was undergoing refurbishment at the time of the fire.

'The fi st possibility is that there was an electrical problem on the 21st fl or, ' said team member César Gomez. 'The second is that someone was negligent, for example a cigarette in a litter bin.

'The third is that there was a problem with the refurbishment work, ' he said.

Bernadette Redfern in Madrid

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

Please remember that the submission of any material is governed by our Terms and Conditions and by submitting material you confirm your agreement to these Terms and Conditions. Please note comments made online may also be published in the print edition of New Civil Engineer. Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.